- Select City
Mahindra Treo Vs Piaggio Ape E City Comparison
- VS
Mahindra Treo vs Piaggio Ape E City
Should you buy Mahindra Treo or Piaggio Ape E City? Compare the models on the basis of their price, dimension, fuel type, payload capacity, Chasis type, number of tyres, GVW & other safety features. Treo has -- cc engine & Ape E City has -- cc engine. Find out which commercial vehicle is best for you.
| Basic Information | ||
|---|---|---|
| Model Name | Treo | Ape E City |
| Brand Name | ||
| On Road Price | ₹ 2.88 Lakh | - |
| User Rating | ||
| Body Type | Auto Rickshaw | Auto Rickshaw |
| Finance Available (EMI) | ₹ 5,579.00 | - |
| Performance | ||
|---|---|---|
| Max Power | 10 hp | 7 hp |
| Displacement (cc) | - | - |
| Fuel Tank (Litres) | - | - |
| Engine | - | Electric Motor |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Electric |
| Emission Norms | BS-VI | BS-VI |
| Max Torque | 42 Nm | 29 Nm |
| Acceleration | - | - |
| Mileage City | - | - |
| Mileage Highway | - | - |
| Top Speed | 55 | 45 |
| Mileage | 131 | 110 |
| Gradeability (%) | 12.7 | 19 |
| Max Speed (km/h) | 55 | - |
| Engine Cylinders | - | - |
| Turning Radius (mm) | 2900 | - |
| Dimension | ||
|---|---|---|
| Overall Length (mm) | 2769 | 2700 |
| Overall Width (mm) | 1350 | 1370 |
| Overall Height (mm) | 1750 | 1725 |
| Ground Clearance (mm) | 142 | 200 |
| Wheelbase (mm) | 2073 | 1920 |
| Axle Configuration | - | - |
| Transmission & Loading Capacity | ||
|---|---|---|
| Transmission | Direct Drive | Constant Mesh 2 Stage Reduction With Integrated Differential Constant |
| Payload (Kgs) | - | 390 |
| GVW / GCW (Kgs) | ||
| Kerb Weight (Kgs) | 377 | 389 |
| Clutch | - | - |
| Power Steering | No | No |
| Features | ||
|---|---|---|
| Steering | Handle Bar | Handle bar type |
| A/C | No | No |
| Cruise Control | No | No |
| Navigation System | No | No |
| Telematics | No | No |
| Tiltable Steering | No | No |
| Arm-rest | No | No |
| Seat Type | Yes | Yes |
| Driver Information Display | Yes | Yes |
| Adjustable Driver Seat | No | No |
| Seating Capacity | D+3 | D + 3 Seater |
| Tubeless Tyres | No | No |
| Seat Belts | - | - |
| Hill Hold | No | Yes |
| Brakes & Suspension | ||
|---|---|---|
| Brakes | Hydraulic Brake | Drum brake hydraulically actuated |
| Front Axle | - | - |
| Front Suspension | Helical spring dampener hydraulic shock absorber | Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Helical Compression Spring with Damper |
| Rear Axle | - | - |
| Rear Suspension | Rigid axle leaf spring | Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Rubber Compression Spring with Damper |
| ABS | No | No |
| Parking Brakes | Yes | Yes |
| Body Option & Cabin Type | ||
|---|---|---|
| Chassis Type | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin |
| Body Option | Fully Built | Fully Built (Soft top) |
| Cabin Type | Day Cabin | Day Cabin |
| Tiltable Cabin | No | No |
| Tyres | ||
|---|---|---|
| Number of Tyre | 3 | 3 |
| Rear Tyre | 10R20 | 4.0 - 8, 4 PR, 70E |
| Front Tyre | 10R20 | 4.0 - 8, 4 PR, 70E |
| Others | ||
|---|---|---|
| No. Of Axles | - | - |
| Axle Types | - | - |
| Body Brakes | - | - |
| Chassis | Yes | Yes |
| Floor Type | - | - |
| Body Material | - | - |
| Canopy Length | - | - |
| Water Tank Type | - | - |
| No. Of Valves | - | - |
| Pump Type | - | - |
| Bulker Type | - | - |
| Bulker Discharge Pipe | - | - |
| Bulker Air Inlet Pipe | - | - |
| Bulker Equipments | - | - |
| Bulker Electricals | - | - |
| Bulker Pressure | - | - |
| Floor Material | - | - |
| Side Board Material | - | - |
| Rear Board Material | - | - |
| External/Interior Surface | - | - |
| Refrigerating Unit | - | - |
| Battery(Volts) | 48 V Lithium-ion | Lithium lon, 48V |
| Fog Lights | - | - |
Pros and Cons
- Pros
- Cons
- Treo overtake any diesel-powered auto-rickshaw in performance, features and revenue earning potentials
- Mahindra's by far the best electric 3W
- Powerful battery and efficient motor
- Durable and strong build quality
- Affordable to buy and economical to run
- The smallest vehicle that comes with a modern lithium-ion battery
- Quite an easy to drive, reasonable speed and range
- A full charge takes relatively lesser time
- Piaggio's Ape E City is one of the top all-electric passenger carrier auto-rickshaw that you can buy right now
- Packed with a powerful motor and modern lithium-ion battery
- Easy charging at home
- Over 100 km of range in a single charge fulfil day long operational needs
- 3 years of free maintenance makes this electric auto quite compelling
- Lower running cost, no worry of increasing fuel cost and Piaggio's widest network for service means relatively peaceful ownership experience
Mahindra Treo
Piaggio Ape E City
- Top variant cost slightly higher
- No fast charing option
- It appears slightly expensive
- Lack of charging network may work against the vehicle
Mahindra Treo
Piaggio Ape E City
Treo Comparison with similar trucks
- VS
Mahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Atul Gem Paxx₹ 2.08 - ₹ 2.50 Lakh * - VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Bajaj Compact RE₹ 2.34 - ₹ 2.36 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Mahindra Alfa₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Piaggio Ape Auto DXLFrom ₹ 2.79 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Piaggio Ape City Plus₹ 2.22 - ₹ 2.55 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Bajaj QuteFrom ₹ 2.65 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Piaggio Ape E CityFrom ₹ 2.84 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Bajaj Maxima X Wide₹ 2.45 - ₹ 2.47 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Piaggio Ape Auto HT DXFrom ₹ 2.56 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *Teja Handy PassangerFrom ₹ 2.32 Lakh *
Ape E City Comparison with similar trucks
- VSPiaggio Ape E CityFrom ₹ 2.84 Lakh *Mahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *
Recommended Auto Rickshaw
- Popular
- Latest
- Tejas Passenger Open BodyPrice Coming Soon
- Power 900 Watt
- GVW -
- Mileage 85-100
- Engine -
- Fuel Tank -
- Payload -
- Tejas Passenger Closed BodyPrice Coming Soon
- Power 900 Watt
- GVW -
- Mileage 70-80
- Engine -
- Fuel Tank -
- Payload -
User Reviews of Comparison
- Mahindra Treo
- Piaggio Ape E City
Do not buy
Chinese e rickshaws are much better and budget friendly. No motor problem. Easy to maintain and cheap spare parts....
very popular Mahindra electric vehicle.
I see more, more Treo in our city, becoming very popular Mahindra electric vehicle. My friend purchased last month, so f...
Not very happy with Treo
Not very happy with Treo because my battery is problem. Full change going down fast, mahindra is fixing the problem but ...
Good weehcle for the more income
I haven't good experience for this whelihcle it's nice good emerge nice prfomence good looking no maintenance...
Value for money auto
I think Treo has some limitation overall but looking at other options, this is one of the best bargain in passenger elec...
Not recommend E city to anyone
Not recommend E city to anyone. I used for six months but facing issues with performance. The battery charing taking tim...
best option
Ape E-City is best option to petorl/CNG rickshaw. Only charigng and no fuel cost. Getting more profit....
Liked this full-electric battery auto-rickshaw.
Liked this full-electric battery operated piaggio Ape auto-rickshaw. 2-3 customer using in our areas, make no sound, dri...
not a powerful electric auto-rickshaw
Ape E City is not a powerful electric auto-rickshaw, the battery needs bigger one and charging time quick. Piaggio shoul...
I recommend to my friend to buy it
Ape E City is a good three-wheeler available in the market. I’m using the vehicle for feeder route, and the average is g...