• Select City

Mahindra Alfa Plus Vs Piaggio Ape E Xtra FX Comparison

  • VS
    ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Mahindra Alfa Plus
    Mahindra Alfa Plus
    ₹2.59 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    View All Offers
    VS
  • ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Piaggio Ape E Xtra FX
    Piaggio Ape E Xtra FX
    ₹3.12 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    View All Offers
Basic Information
Model Name
Alfa Plus
Ape E Xtra FX
Brand Name
On Road Price
₹2.59 Lakh
₹3.12 Lakh
User Rating
4.1
Based on 21 Reviews
4.7
Based on 13 Reviews
Body Type
3 Wheeler
3 Wheeler
Finance Available (EMI)
₹5,010.00
₹6,038.00
Performance
Max Power
9.5 hp
12 hp
Engine
Single Cylinder Direct Injection DI,Air cooled
Electric Motor
Fuel Type
CNG
Electric
Max Torque
23.5 Nm
45 Nm
Max Speed (km/h)
53
45
Battery Capacity
50 Ah
9.55 Kwh
Dimension
Overall Length (mm)
3210
3315
Overall Width (mm)
1460
1490
Overall Height (mm)
1815
1770
Ground Clearance (mm)
175
220
Wheelbase (mm)
2165
2100
Transmission & Loading Capacity
Transmission
Manual
PT gear with differential (Integral)
Payload (Kgs)
435
506
GVW / GCW (Kgs)
Kerb Weight (Kgs)
560
480
Power SteeringNoNo
Features
Steering
Handle Bar
Handle bar type
A/CNoNo
Cruise ControlNoNo
Navigation SystemNoNo
TelematicsNoNo
Tiltable SteeringNoNo
Arm-restNoNo
Seat TypeYesYes
Driver Information DisplayYesYes
Adjustable Driver SeatYesNo
Seating Capacity
D+1
Driver Only
Tubeless TyresNoNo
Seat BeltsYesNo
Hill HoldNoYes
Brakes & Suspension
Brakes
Drum Brakes with leading & trailing shoes
Drum Brake hydraulically actuated internal expanding shoe type
Front Suspension
Swing Arm,Coin Spring,Telescopic Hydraulic Shok Absorber
Helical spring with dampener
Rear Suspension
Rubber Spring, Telescopic Hydraulic Shok Absorber
Rubber Spring with damper
ABSNoNo
Parking BrakesYesYes
Body Option & Cabin Type
Chassis Type
Chassis with Cabin
Chassis with Cabin
Body Option
Deck Body
Deck Body
Cabin Type
Day Cabin
Day Cabin
Tiltable CabinNoNo
Tyres
Number of Tyre
3
3
Rear Tyre
4.50 x 10-8 PR
120/80 R 12
Front Tyre
4.50 x 10-8 PR
120/80 R 12
Others
ChassisYesYes

Pros and Cons

  • Pros
  • Cons

    Mahindra Alfa Plus

    • A powerful, high mileage cargo three-wheeler.
    • Alfa is a capable vehicle that promises a greater payload.
    • Strong, rugged and reliable cargo auto suitable for all kinds of logistics operations.
    • A versatile auto that has a feature-packed, roomy cabin with lots of storage space.
    • Stand out features include a bottle holder, speakers, wider and comfortable driver seats, lockable box & stylish instrument panel.
    • High good ground clearance and better pickups mean your delivery is assured fast and quick.
    • A bigger cargo load body helps carry heavy & voluminous cargo.

    Piaggio Ape E Xtra FX

    • Piaggio is offering its most popular cargo auto-rickshaw in electric avatar with equal value for money proposition
    • The 6ft cargo deck is large with a lot of pulling power on all types of terrains
    • The built quality of this electric cargo auto is at par with its diesel counterpart
    • Benefits of lower running cost, zero noise and pollutions
    • 90 km of range of single charge should last day-long operations
    • Superbly packed zero pollution vehicle from the market leader that comes with embedded iconnect telematics solutions for better vehicle utilisation
    • 500 kg of payload is a good bargain for an all-electric cargo three-wheeler

    Mahindra Alfa Plus

    • Alfa Plus faced tough competition in the segment and could make an impact with more high fuel efficiency.
    • Among the missing features is a mobile charging point.
    • More model variants would make the Alfa appealing in the segment.

    Piaggio Ape E Xtra FX

    • The nearly 4 hours battery charging time is too high
    • Scope to improve on key specs
    • 45 km/h top-speed looks on the lower side
    • A more powerful, long-range variant would appeal to a wider customer base

Alfa Plus Comparison with similar trucks

Ape E Xtra FX Comparison with similar trucks

Recommended 3 Wheeler

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
    ₹2.45 - ₹2.48 Lakh*
    • Power 9.4 hp
    • GVW 975
    • Mileage 22
    • Engine 599
    • Fuel Tank 10.5
    • Fuel Type Diesel
    View All Offers
  • Bajaj Maxima C
    Bajaj Maxima C
    ₹2.83 - ₹2.84 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 965
    • Mileage 33
    • Engine 470.5
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Fuel Type Diesel
    View All Offers
  • Mahindra Alfa Plus
    Mahindra Alfa Plus
    ₹2.59 - ₹2.85 Lakh*
    • Power 9 hp
    • GVW 995
    • Mileage 29.4
    • Engine 597
    • Fuel Tank 40
    • Payload 505
    View All Offers
  • Electric
    Mahindra Treo Zor
    Mahindra Treo Zor
    ₹3.13 - ₹3.48 Lakh*
    • Power 8 kW
    • GVW 995
    • Payload 550
    • Fuel Type Electric
    View All Offers
  • Electric
    Mahindra Zor Grand
    Mahindra Zor Grand
    ₹3.50 - ₹3.80 Lakh*
    • Power 12 kW
    • GVW 998
    • Payload 400
    • Fuel Type Electric
    View All Offers

User Reviews of Comparison

  • Mahindra Alfa Plus
  • Piaggio Ape E Xtra FX
  • Reliable and capable

    Need to carry some good load of cargo over a short distance? Need an efficient three wheeler for the Indian roads? I wil...

    By venkatramani j.
    On: Jan 24, 2023
  • Bilkul nahi

    Abb Tak ka subse bekar Auto hai Eske pats nahi milte hai Aur Agence pat Mahege milte hai ek saensar 5.000 Ka milta hai...

    By dalip kumar
    On: Dec 30, 2022
  • Engine problem

    Mene 4 month pehle alfa load liya faience par 11100rs emi hai 4month mai itni problem hai dur nhi ho rhi bahut pareshan ...

    By mudaisar
    On: Dec 17, 2022
  • Kaafi badi load body aur acchi load capacity

    Mahindra Alfa Plus Indian market mein three wheeler cargo carrier segment ki ek behtareen option hai. Kareeb do saal se ...

    By sumeet k.
    On: Dec 08, 2022
  • Very bad experience

    I am running an agency. I bought this 3 wheelet on oct 21. It is going to be 11months of this van but within this 11 mon...

    By kumar ravi ranjan
    On: Oct 08, 2022
  • Reliable cargo three-wheeler

    If you need a three wheeler cargo carrier with good capacity for short distance load carrying, then the Piaggio Ape E Xt...

    By gautam tyagi
    On: Oct 27, 2022
  • Ek bharosemand cargo carrier

    Three wheeler cargo segment mein Piaggio Ape E Xtra ek bohot hi acchi choice hai. Kaafi sari three wheelers chalane ...

    By kunal
    On: Sept 07, 2022
  • Ek bharosemaand three wheeler cargo carrier

    Agar apko load carriage ke liye ek affordable aur bharosemaand three wheeler truck chahiye toh. Piaggio Ape E Xtra...

    By vinod
    On: Aug 26, 2022
  • Kaafi capable electric cargo three wheeler

    Main kuch mahino se Piaggio Ape E Xtra chala raha hoon, aur mere opinion mein, three wheeler load carrier ke his...

    By mohammad jamim
    On: Aug 05, 2022
  • Happy customer of Piaggio Ape E Xtra

    My experience with This Piaggio Ape electric three-wheeler for last 6 months is actually good. After driving the diesel ...

    By vinoth kumar
    On: Jul 27, 2022
×
Which is your city ?