• Select City

Mahindra Alfa Vs Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX Comparison

  • VS
    ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Mahindra Alfa
    Mahindra Alfa
    ₹2.88 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    View All Offers
    VS
  • ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
    ₹2.45 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    View All Offers
Basic Information
Model Name
Alfa
Ape Xtra LDX
Brand Name
On Road Price
₹2.88 Lakh
₹2.45 Lakh
User Rating
4.6
Based on 20 Reviews
4.8
Based on 19 Reviews
Body Type
Auto Rickshaw
3 Wheeler
Finance Available (EMI)
₹5,574.00
₹4,797.00
Performance
Max Power
9 hp
9.4 hp
Displacement (cc)
597
599
Fuel Tank (Litres)
10.5
10.5
Engine
4 Stroke Single Cylinder Water Cooled Diesel
Single Cylinder water Cooled
Fuel Type
Diesel
Diesel
Emission Norms
BS-VI
BS-VI
Max Torque
23.5 Nm
23.5 Nm
Acceleration
-
-
Mileage City
-
-
Mileage Highway
-
-
Mileage
28.9
22
Gradeability (%)
-
-
Max Speed (km/h)
54
60
Engine Cylinders
1
1
Dimension
Overall Length (mm)
3025
3145
Overall Width (mm)
1480
1490
Overall Height (mm)
1930
1770
Ground Clearance (mm)
175
245
Wheelbase (mm)
2005
2100
Axle Configuration
-
-
Transmission & Loading Capacity
Transmission
Manual
Constant mesh
Payload (Kgs)
-
-
GVW / GCW (Kgs)
Kerb Weight (Kgs)
515
479
Gear Box
5 Forward + 1 Reverse
5 Forward + 1 Reverse
Clutch
Multi plate weight clutch
Multi Disc Wet Type
Power SteeringNoNo
Features
Steering
Handle Bar
Handle Bar
A/CNoNo
Cruise ControlNoNo
Navigation SystemNoNo
TelematicsNoNo
Tiltable SteeringNoNo
Arm-restNoNo
Seat TypeYesYes
Driver Information DisplayYesYes
Adjustable Driver SeatNoNo
Seating Capacity
D+3 Passenger
Driver Only
Tubeless TyresNoNo
Seat BeltsNoNo
Hill HoldNoNo
Brakes & Suspension
Brakes
Dual circuit internal expanding type Hydraulic Brake with Auto Adjuster
Drum Brake
Front Axle
-
-
Front Suspension
Coil spring, hydraulic shock absorber with anti dive leading link
Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Helical Compression Spring with Damper
Rear Axle
-
-
Rear Suspension
Car like Coil Spring with independent swinging arm, hydraulic shock absorber
Rubber Spring with damper
ABSNoNo
Parking BrakesYesYes
Body Option & Cabin Type
Chassis Type
Chassis with Cabin
Chassis with Cabin
Body Option
Fuliy Bulit
Deck Body
Cabin Type
Day Cabin
Day Cabin
Tiltable CabinNoNo
Tyres
Number of Tyre
3
3
Rear Tyre
4.50 X 10 - 8 PR
4.50 - 10, 8 PR
Front Tyre
4.50 X 10 - 8 PR
4.50 - 10, 8 PR
Others
No. Of Axles
-
-
Axle Types
-
-
Body Brakes
-
-
ChassisYesYes
Floor Type
-
-
Body Material
-
-
Canopy Length
-
-
Water Tank Capacity (KL)
-
-
Water Tank Type
-
-
No. Of Valves
-
-
Pump Type
-
-
Bulker Type
-
-
Bulker Discharge Pipe
-
-
Bulker Air Inlet Pipe
-
-
Bulker Equipments
-
-
Bulker Electricals
-
-
Bulker Pressure
-
-
Floor Material
-
-
Side Board Material
-
-
Rear Board Material
-
-
External/Interior Surface
-
-
Refrigerating Unit
-
-
Temperature Range
-
-
Battery(Volts)
12 V
12V DC 50Ah
Fog Lights
-
No

Pros and Cons

  • Pros
  • Cons

    Mahindra Alfa

    • Highly competitive auto-rickshaw segment, Alfa impress with its overall design and road presence
    • Overall bigger size auto & large, roomy passenger cabin
    • Comfortable driver position with easy to drive
    • Passenger cabin with door for higher safety
    • Superior performance makes its worthy rival in the passenger auto-rickshaw category
    • Multiple variants for a variety of customer needs and applications
    • Proven powertrain, durable aggregates & higher mileage

    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX

    • The reliability, practicality and performance makes Ape Xtra LDX is the most popular cargo three-wheelers in India
    • A strong & rugged cargo three-wheeler
    • Easy to operate and navigate
    • Highly economical to run & affordable to own
    • Multiple cargo body options available

    Mahindra Alfa

    • A bigger tyre variant will be a good choice
    • Only diesel powertrain
    • Bigger fuel tank will avoid frequent refill breaks
    • No standard entertainment feature

    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX

    • The display on the dashboard is tiny
    • The 10.5L fuel tank is slightly small
    • A marginal increase in rated payload could add more value to this 3W

Alfa Comparison with similar trucks

Ape Xtra LDX Comparison with similar trucks

Popular Models

  • Auto Rickshaw
  • 3 Wheeler
  • Electric
    Mahindra Treo
    Mahindra Treo
    ₹2.92 - ₹3.02 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 350
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Bajaj Compact RE
    Bajaj Compact RE
    ₹2.34 - ₹2.36 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 672
    • Mileage 40
    • Engine 236.2
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • TVS King Deluxe
    TVS King Deluxe
    ₹1.20 - ₹1.35 Lakh*
    • Power 10.46 hp
    • GVW NA
    • Mileage 42.34
    • Engine 199.26
    • Fuel Tank 8.5
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Electric
    Piaggio Ape E City
    Piaggio Ape E City
    ₹1.95 - ₹2.84 Lakh*
    • Power 7.3 Hp
    • GVW 689
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload 390
    View All Offers
  • Bajaj Maxima Z
    Bajaj Maxima Z
    ₹1.96 - ₹1.98 Lakh*
    • Power 8 hp
    • GVW 790
    • Mileage 29.4
    • Engine 470.5
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Electric
    Bajaj Maxima Cargo E-TEC 9.0
    Bajaj Maxima Cargo E-TEC 9.0
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power 6 Hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Electric
    Bajaj Maxima Xl Cargo E-TEC 12.0
    Bajaj Maxima Xl Cargo E-TEC 12.0
    From ₹3.77 Lakh*
    • Power 7 hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
    ₹2.45 - ₹2.48 Lakh*
    • Power 9.4 hp
    • GVW 975
    • Mileage 22
    • Engine 599
    • Fuel Tank 10.5
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Bajaj Maxima C
    Bajaj Maxima C
    ₹2.83 - ₹2.84 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 965
    • Mileage 33
    • Engine 470.5
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    View All Offers
  • Mahindra Alfa Plus
    Mahindra Alfa Plus
    ₹2.59 - ₹2.85 Lakh*
    • Power 9 hp
    • GVW 995
    • Mileage 29.4
    • Engine 597
    • Payload 505
    • Fuel Type Diesel
    View All Offers

User Reviews of Comparison

  • Mahindra Alfa
  • Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX
  • Spacious three wheeler with good mileage

    Mahindra Alfa is good value for money and budget vehicle that is suitable for both driver and the load it bears. It also...

    By jasneet
    On: Aug 21, 2023
  • Aatma Vishwas se Bhara Safar

    Mahindra Alfa ek kaarigar aur chhote vyavasaayiyo ke liye ek shandar vahan hai. Is gaadi ki takatvar engine aur sudridh ...

    By annu yadav
    On: Aug 07, 2023
  • Mahindra Alfa designed for transportation needs

    Mahindra Alfa is a mini truck that is designed for urban and rural transportation needs. Its Compact size makes it easy ...

    By shamsher
    On: Apr 11, 2023
  • Spacious and comfortable

    Auto rickshaw has been my business for close to 10 years now and I own seven auto rickshaws right now. Amongst them, the...

    By raghavan m.
    On: Jan 24, 2023
  • Accha performance aur capacity

    Kareeb ek saal se main Mahindra Alfa chala raha hoon. Indian market mein abhi jitni bhi auto rickshaws hai, un sab mein ...

    By virendra mehra
    On: Dec 08, 2022
  • Desi Power with Modern Charm!

    Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX ek kamal ka vehicle hai jiske saath hume desi power aur modern charm dono milte hain. Iska design k...

    By jugnu
    On: Aug 07, 2023
  • Affordable and profitable

    Good for all cargo delivery. Best cargo auto rikshaw in India. It's Budget-friendly and low maintenance cost. Happy to h...

    By prashant mehta
    On: Nov 04, 2022
  • Good cargo auto rickshaw of heavy load

    I purchased the Ape Xtra LDX for local cargo delivery with a very good price deal by the dealership with exchange of my ...

    By pratap sharma
    On: Jul 05, 2022
  • आपे लोडीग आटो

    हमें मोढे मे गाड़ी लगानी है और हम सीमेंट काम करना है हम हमाली करना चाहतें है और हम गाडी नयी खरीदनी है...

    By शेख मजनु शेख हाबीब
    On: Apr 10, 2022
  • High payload auto rickshaw

    High payload auto rickshaw in India. Ape LDX cheap and best, mileage, cargo deck and also features. No 1 auto rickshaw f...

    By harsha kumar
    On: Apr 07, 2022
×
Which is your city ?