- Select City
Mahindra Alfa Vs Piaggio Ape E City Comparison
- VS
Mahindra Alfa vs Piaggio Ape E City
Should you buy Mahindra Alfa or Piaggio Ape E City? Compare the models on the basis of their price, dimension, fuel type, payload capacity, Chasis type, number of tyres, GVW & other safety features. Alfa has 597 cc engine & Ape E City has -- cc engine. Find out which commercial vehicle is best for you.
| Basic Information | ||
|---|---|---|
| Model Name | Alfa | Ape E City |
| Brand Name | ||
| On Road Price | ₹ 2.88 Lakh | - |
| User Rating | ||
| Body Type | Auto Rickshaw | Auto Rickshaw |
| Finance Available (EMI) | ₹ 5,574.00 | - |
| Performance | ||
|---|---|---|
| Max Power | 9 hp | 7 hp |
| Displacement (cc) | 597 | - |
| Fuel Tank (Litres) | 10.5 | - |
| Engine | Four Stroke Single Cylinder Water Cooled Diesel Engine | Electric Motor |
| Fuel Type | Diesel | Electric |
| Emission Norms | BS-VI | BS-VI |
| Max Torque | 23.5 Nm | 29 Nm |
| Acceleration | - | - |
| Mileage City | - | - |
| Mileage Highway | - | - |
| Top Speed | - | 45 |
| Mileage | 28.9 | 110 |
| Gradeability (%) | - | 19 |
| Max Speed (km/h) | 54 | - |
| Engine Cylinders | 1 | - |
| Turning Radius (mm) | 1750 | - |
| Dimension | ||
|---|---|---|
| Overall Length (mm) | 3025 | 2700 |
| Overall Width (mm) | 1480 | 1370 |
| Overall Height (mm) | 1930 | 1725 |
| Ground Clearance (mm) | 170 | 200 |
| Wheelbase (mm) | 2005 | 1920 |
| Axle Configuration | - | - |
| Transmission & Loading Capacity | ||
|---|---|---|
| Transmission | Manual | Constant Mesh 2 Stage Reduction With Integrated Differential Constant |
| Payload (Kgs) | - | 390 |
| GVW / GCW (Kgs) | ||
| Kerb Weight (Kgs) | 515 | 389 |
| Clutch | Multi plate wet clutch | - |
| Power Steering | No | No |
| Features | ||
|---|---|---|
| Steering | Handle Bar | Handle bar type |
| A/C | No | No |
| Cruise Control | No | No |
| Navigation System | No | No |
| Telematics | No | No |
| Tiltable Steering | No | No |
| Arm-rest | No | No |
| Seat Type | Yes | Yes |
| Driver Information Display | Yes | Yes |
| Adjustable Driver Seat | No | No |
| Seating Capacity | D+3 Passenger | D + 3 Seater |
| Tubeless Tyres | No | No |
| Seat Belts | - | - |
| Hill Hold | No | Yes |
| Brakes & Suspension | ||
|---|---|---|
| Brakes | Hydraulic Brake | Drum brake hydraulically actuated |
| Front Axle | - | - |
| Front Suspension | Coil spring, hydraulic shock absorber with anti dive leading link | Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Helical Compression Spring with Damper |
| Rear Axle | - | - |
| Rear Suspension | Rubber spring with independent swinging arm & hydraulic shock absorber | Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Rubber Compression Spring with Damper |
| ABS | No | No |
| Parking Brakes | Yes | Yes |
| Body Option & Cabin Type | ||
|---|---|---|
| Chassis Type | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin |
| Body Option | Fuliy Bulit | Fully Built (Soft top) |
| Cabin Type | Day Cabin | Day Cabin |
| Tiltable Cabin | No | No |
| Tyres | ||
|---|---|---|
| Number of Tyre | 3 | 3 |
| Rear Tyre | 4.50 X 10 - 8 PR | 4.0 - 8, 4 PR, 70E |
| Front Tyre | 4.50 X 10 - 8 PR | 4.0 - 8, 4 PR, 70E |
| Others | ||
|---|---|---|
| No. Of Axles | - | - |
| Axle Types | - | - |
| Body Brakes | - | - |
| Chassis | Yes | Yes |
| Floor Type | - | - |
| Body Material | - | - |
| Canopy Length | - | - |
| Water Tank Capacity (KL) | - | - |
| Water Tank Type | - | - |
| No. Of Valves | - | - |
| Pump Type | - | - |
| Bulker Type | - | - |
| Bulker Discharge Pipe | - | - |
| Bulker Air Inlet Pipe | - | - |
| Bulker Equipments | - | - |
| Bulker Electricals | - | - |
| Bulker Pressure | - | - |
| Floor Material | - | - |
| Side Board Material | - | - |
| Rear Board Material | - | - |
| External/Interior Surface | - | - |
| Refrigerating Unit | - | - |
| Temperature Range | - | - |
| Battery(Volts) | 12 V 50 Ah | Lithium lon, 48V |
| Fog Lights | - | - |
Pros and Cons
- Pros
- Cons
- Highly competitive auto-rickshaw segment, Alfa impress with its overall design and road presence
- Overall bigger size auto & large, roomy passenger cabin
- Comfortable driver position with easy to drive
- Passenger cabin with door for higher safety
- Superior performance makes its worthy rival in the passenger auto-rickshaw category
- Multiple variants for a variety of customer needs and applications
- Proven powertrain, durable aggregates & higher mileage
- Piaggio's Ape E City is one of the top all-electric passenger carrier auto-rickshaw that you can buy right now
- Packed with a powerful motor and modern lithium-ion battery
- Easy charging at home
- Over 100 km of range in a single charge fulfil day long operational needs
- 3 years of free maintenance makes this electric auto quite compelling
- Lower running cost, no worry of increasing fuel cost and Piaggio's widest network for service means relatively peaceful ownership experience
Mahindra Alfa
Piaggio Ape E City
- A bigger tyre variant will be a good choice
- Only diesel powertrain
- Bigger fuel tank will avoid frequent refill breaks
- No standard entertainment feature
- It appears slightly expensive
- Lack of charging network may work against the vehicle
Mahindra Alfa
Piaggio Ape E City
Alfa Comparison with similar trucks
- VS
Mahindra Alfa₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh *Piaggio Ape Auto DX₹ 3.52 - ₹ 3.54 Lakh * - VSMahindra Alfa₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh *Bajaj Maxima X Wide₹ 2.45 - ₹ 2.47 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Alfa₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh *Bajaj Compact RE₹ 2.34 - ₹ 2.36 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Alfa₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh *Piaggio Ape Xtra LDX₹ 2.45 - ₹ 2.48 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Alfa₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh *Atul Gem Paxx₹ 2.08 - ₹ 2.50 Lakh *
Ape E City Comparison with similar trucks
- VSPiaggio Ape E CityFrom ₹ 2.84 Lakh *Mahindra Treo₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh *
Recommended Auto Rickshaw
- Popular
- Latest
User Reviews of Comparison
- Mahindra Alfa
- Piaggio Ape E City
Bigger size
Bigger size auto rickshaw is Alfa for 3-4 passenger and also mahindra giving powerful engine with this auto. Other good ...
more load capacity
The new alfa get bigger cargo body, more load capacity, mileage is ok. super vehicle from mahindra. ...
good auto-rickshaw for my usage.
Mahindra Alfa purchased 3 months ago, good auto-rickshaw for my usage. Happy with performance-getting good mileage, bs6 ...
Kunal Singh Rajput mera naam hua aise log pyar se
मैंने अपनी जितनी भी कार्य गाड़ी खरीदी vah sab ki sab acchi malish jaati hai achcha chalta bhi hai sab gadi chal rahi hai...
You can buy any auto-rickahw
You can buy any auto-rickahw bajaj, mahindra, piaggio. All of them good. The new Alfa from mahindra is also good, the en...
Not very great e rickshaw
Not very happy with this Ape electric auto rickshaw. running cost is low but battery performance is not good, charging g...
Good CNG options autorickshaw
I think Piaggio electric auto rickshaw is good. Only charging time and range km is problem. But overall options for dies...
Efficient aur affordable Piaggio Ape e-auto
Piaggio Ape toh auto rickshaw ka market mein puri India mein hi bohot popular hai. Electric option mein Piaggio Ape E Ci...
மிகவும் பரிந்துரைக்கப்பட்ட Ape E நகரம்
Nakara payaṇikaḷ pōkkuvarattu vaṇikattiṟku oru nalla vaḻi. Ṭīcal/ci'eṉji allatu Petrol, Diesel, CNG viṭa vilai atikam āṉ...
Not recommend E city to anyone
Not recommend E city to anyone. I used for six months but facing issues with performance. The battery charing taking tim...