• Select City

Mahindra Alfa Vs Piaggio Ape City Plus Comparison

  • VS
    ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Mahindra Alfa
    Mahindra Alfa
    ₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.89 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    Talk To Dealer
    VS
  • ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Piaggio Ape City Plus
    Piaggio Ape City Plus
    ₹ 2.22 - ₹ 2.55 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    Talk To Dealer

Mahindra Alfa vs Piaggio Ape City Plus

Should you buy Mahindra Alfa or Piaggio Ape City Plus? Compare the models on the basis of their price, dimension, fuel type, payload capacity, Chasis type, number of tyres, GVW & other safety features. Alfa has 597 cc engine & Ape City Plus has 230 cc engine. Find out which commercial vehicle is best for you.

Read More...
Basic Information
Model Name
Alfa
Ape City Plus
Brand Name
On Road Price
₹ 2.88 Lakh
₹ 2.22 Lakh
User Rating
4.8
Based on 13 Reviews
4.9
Based on 13 Reviews
Body Type
Auto Rickshaw
Auto Rickshaw
Finance Available (EMI)
₹ 5,574.00
₹ 4,932.00
Performance
Max Power
9 hp
9.9 hp
Displacement (cc)
597
230
Fuel Tank (Litres)
10.5
20.6/Petrol 2.8
Engine
Four Stroke Single Cylinder Water Cooled Diesel Engine
Forced Air Cooled
Fuel Type
Diesel
LPG
Emission Norms
BS-VI
BS-VI
Max Torque
23.5 Nm
17.8 Nm
Acceleration
-
-
Mileage City
-
-
Mileage Highway
-
-
Top Speed
-
-
Mileage
28.9
22
Gradeability (%)
-
25.45
Max Speed (km/h)
54
60
Engine Cylinders
1
1
Turning Radius (mm)
1750
-
Dimension
Overall Length (mm)
3025
2880
Overall Width (mm)
1480
1435
Overall Height (mm)
1930
1920
Ground Clearance (mm)
170
200
Wheelbase (mm)
2005
1920
Axle Configuration
-
-
Transmission & Loading Capacity
Transmission
Manual
Manual
Payload (Kgs)
-
-
GVW / GCW (Kgs)
Kerb Weight (Kgs)
515
457
Gear Box
5-Speed
4-Speed
Clutch
Multi plate wet clutch
Multi-Plate, Wet Type
Power SteeringNoNo
Features
Steering
Handle Bar
Handle Bar
A/CNoNo
Cruise ControlNoNo
Navigation SystemNoNo
TelematicsNoNo
Tiltable SteeringNoNo
Arm-restNoNo
Seat TypeYesYes
Driver Information DisplayYesYes
Adjustable Driver SeatNoNo
Seating Capacity
D+3 Passenger
D+3
Tubeless TyresNoNo
Seat Belts
-
-
Hill HoldNoNo
Brakes & Suspension
Brakes
Hydraulic Brake
Drum Brake
Front Axle
-
-
Front Suspension
Coil spring, hydraulic shock absorber with anti dive leading link
Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Helical Compression Spring with Damper
Rear Axle
-
-
Rear Suspension
Rubber spring with independent swinging arm & hydraulic shock absorber
Hydraulic Telescopic Shock Absorber with Rubber Compression Spring with Damper
ABSNoNo
Parking BrakesYesYes
Body Option & Cabin Type
Chassis Type
Chassis with Cabin
Chassis with Cabin
Body Option
Fuliy Bulit
Fuliy Bulit
Cabin Type
Day Cabin
Day Cabin
Tiltable CabinNoNo
Tyres
Number of Tyre
3
3
Rear Tyre
4.50 X 10 - 8 PR
4.50 - 10, 4 PR
Front Tyre
4.50 X 10 - 8 PR
4.50 - 10, 4 PR
Others
No. Of Axles
-
-
Axle Types
-
-
Body Brakes
-
-
ChassisYesYes
Floor Type
-
-
Body Material
-
-
Canopy Length
-
-
Water Tank Capacity (KL)
-
-
Water Tank Type
-
-
No. Of Valves
-
-
Pump Type
-
-
Bulker Type
-
-
Bulker Discharge Pipe
-
-
Bulker Air Inlet Pipe
-
-
Bulker Equipments
-
-
Bulker Electricals
-
-
Bulker Pressure
-
-
Floor Material
-
-
Side Board Material
-
-
Rear Board Material
-
-
External/Interior Surface
-
-
Refrigerating Unit
-
-
Temperature Range
-
-
Battery(Volts)
12 V 50 Ah
12 V 40 Ah
Fog Lights
-
-

Pros and Cons

  • Pros
  • Cons

    Mahindra Alfa

    • Highly competitive auto-rickshaw segment, Alfa impress with its overall design and road presence
    • Overall bigger size auto & large, roomy passenger cabin
    • Comfortable driver position with easy to drive
    • Passenger cabin with door for higher safety
    • Superior performance makes its worthy rival in the passenger auto-rickshaw category
    • Multiple variants for a variety of customer needs and applications
    • Proven powertrain, durable aggregates & higher mileage

    Piaggio Ape City Plus

    • Top three-wheeler from Ape brand that you can buy in petrol, CNG or LPG fuel options
    • Visually appealing, Ape City+ is a proven auto-rickshaw that you can pick for your daily passenger mobility needs
    • Piaggio new 3V smart engines stand out for high power and torque that promise superior mileage
    • The 4.5- 10 4 PR tyre and higher ground clearance means the Ape City+ is good for rural roads too
    • Ape City+ is affordable yet well-packed with comfort and convenience features that you will find in the segment

    Mahindra Alfa

    • A bigger tyre variant will be a good choice
    • Only diesel powertrain
    • Bigger fuel tank will avoid frequent refill breaks
    • No standard entertainment feature

    Piaggio Ape City Plus

    • Ape City + is a practical, easy to the drive and well designed auto-rickshaw with hardly misses anything that you would expect

Alfa Comparison with similar trucks

Ape City Plus Comparison with similar trucks

Recommended Auto Rickshaw

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Mahindra Treo
    Mahindra Treo
    ₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 350
    • Mileage 141
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Bajaj Compact RE
    Bajaj Compact RE
    ₹ 2.34 - ₹ 2.36 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 672
    • Mileage 40
    • Engine 236.2
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Mahindra E-Alfa mini
    Mahindra E-Alfa mini
    From ₹ 1.45 Lakh*
    • Power 2 hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage 85
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Bajaj Maxima Z
    Bajaj Maxima Z
    ₹ 1.96 - ₹ 1.98 Lakh*
    • Power 8 hp
    • GVW 790
    • Mileage -
    • Engine 470.5
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Piaggio Ape E City
    Piaggio Ape E City
    From ₹ 2.84 Lakh*
    • Power 7 hp
    • GVW 713
    • Mileage 110
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload 390
    Talk To Dealer
  • Avon E-Auto Greenway
    Avon E-Auto Greenway
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power -
    • GVW -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    • Fuel Type -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Avon E-Rick 207 Butterfly
    Avon E-Rick 207 Butterfly
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power -
    • GVW -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    • Fuel Type -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Terra Motors Y4A
    Terra Motors Y4A
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power -
    • GVW 270
    • Mileage 80
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Terra Motors X1
    Terra Motors X1
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power -
    • GVW 296
    • Mileage 80
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Terra Motors Sumo
    Terra Motors Sumo
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power -
    • GVW 296
    • Mileage 80
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer

User Reviews of Comparison

  • Mahindra Alfa
  • Piaggio Ape City Plus
  • Bigger size

    Bigger size auto rickshaw is Alfa for 3-4 passenger and also mahindra giving powerful engine with this auto. Other good ...

    By atul halge
    On: Apr 19, 2022
  • more load capacity

    The new alfa get bigger cargo body, more load capacity, mileage is ok. super vehicle from mahindra. ...

    By arif ali
    On: Feb 09, 2022
  • good auto-rickshaw for my usage.

    Mahindra Alfa purchased 3 months ago, good auto-rickshaw for my usage. Happy with performance-getting good mileage, bs6 ...

    By shailesh
    On: Jan 04, 2022
  • Kunal Singh Rajput mera naam hua aise log pyar se

    मैंने अपनी जितनी भी कार्य गाड़ी खरीदी vah sab ki sab acchi malish jaati hai achcha chalta bhi hai sab gadi chal rahi hai...

    By kundan kumar
    On: Dec 26, 2021
  • You can buy any auto-rickahw

    You can buy any auto-rickahw bajaj, mahindra, piaggio. All of them good. The new Alfa from mahindra is also good, the en...

    By ghanshyam patel
    On: Nov 22, 2021
  • good for city passenger travel.

    Piaggio auto rickshaw is good for city passenger travel. High mileage, high build quality and mileage is super…go if you...

    By prince
    On: Apr 24, 2022
  • Best auto in India

    Ape is Best auto in India. Buy for anytime business. Cheap and best auto rickshaw.....

    By sujay pant
    On: Mar 21, 2022
  • Not a good auto

    Not a good auto like Bajaj RE. You buy RE only not Ape. ...

    By sanjay yadav
    On: Feb 10, 2022
  • Not a bad auto-rickshaw

    Not a bad auto-rickshaw from Piaggio, the cng viant engine vehicle is best. Mileage is high and power is better also. Pa...

    By sachin
    On: Jan 04, 2022
  • I liked Ape auto

    I liked Ape auto and want to buy for rickshaw use but Piaggio has Ape DX, Ape City & Ape City Plus- I confused about whi...

    By prakash joshi
    On: Nov 24, 2021
×
Which is your city ?