- Select City
Kinetic Safar Smart Vs Mahindra Treo Yaari Comparison
- VS
| Basic Information | ||
|---|---|---|
| Model Name | Safar Smart | Treo Yaari |
| Brand Name | ||
| On Road Price | ₹1.45 Lakh | ₹1.79 Lakh |
| User Rating | ||
| Body Type | Auto Rickshaw | Auto Rickshaw |
| Finance Available (EMI) | ₹2,804.00 | ₹3,457.00 |
| Performance | ||
|---|---|---|
| Max Power | 1 hp | 2 hp |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Electric |
| Gradeability (%) | 10.2 | 7 |
| Range | 70 | 125 |
| Battery Capacity | 140 Ah | 3.69 |
| Type of Motor | BLDC Motor | AC induction motor |
| Product Type | L3M (Low Speed Passenger Carrier) | L3M (Low Speed Passenger Carrier) |
| Charging | ||
|---|---|---|
| Charging Time | 2 hrs | 2 h 30 min |
| Dimension | ||
|---|---|---|
| Overall Length (mm) | 2785 | 2769 |
| Overall Width (mm) | 998 | 995 |
| Overall Height (mm) | 1790 | 1750 |
| Ground Clearance (mm) | 220 | 142 |
| Transmission & Loading Capacity | ||
|---|---|---|
| Transmission | Direct Drive | Direct Drive |
| GVW / GCW (Kgs) | ||
| Gear Box | 1 Forward +1 Reverse | 1 Forward +1 Reverse |
| Power Steering | No | No |
| Features | ||
|---|---|---|
| Steering | Handle Bar | Handle Bar |
| A/C | No | No |
| Cruise Control | No | No |
| Telematics | No | No |
| Tiltable Steering | No | No |
| Arm-rest | No | No |
| Seat Type | Yes | Yes |
| Driver Information Display | Yes | Yes |
| Adjustable Driver Seat | No | No |
| Seating Capacity | D+4 | D+4 |
| Tubeless Tyres | No | No |
| Brakes & Suspension | ||
|---|---|---|
| Brakes | Drum Brake | Mechanical Brake |
| ABS | No | No |
| Parking Brakes | Yes | Yes |
| Body Option & Cabin Type | ||
|---|---|---|
| Chassis Type | Chassis with Cabin | Chassis with Cabin |
| Body Option | Fuliy Bulit | Fully Bulit |
| Cabin Type | Day Cabin | Day Cabin |
| Tiltable Cabin | No | No |
| Tyres | ||
|---|---|---|
| Number of Tyre | 3 | 3 |
| Others | ||
|---|---|---|
| Chassis | Yes | Yes |
Pros and Cons
- Pros
- Cons
- Real driving range of 80-100 km makes the Safar Smart a highly useful e-rickshaw for daily business trips
- Lithium/Lead Acid Battery options
- All steel body construction makes it safer and more reliable
- Superior built quality and excellent road presence
- High-quality aggregates like brakes, suspension, tyre.
- Comfortable passenger cabin with high leg, knee and shoulder room.
- 3 years warranty instil confidence in the e-rickshaw
- Treo is powerful, features a rich all-electric auto-rickshaw out in the market.
- Powerful lithium-ion battery and superior built quality.
- Higher running range of over 90 km in a single charge.
- Higher payload and comfortable and safe passenger cabin.
- Highly affordable e-rickshaw in the segment, the lowest running cost a huge advantage against the IC engine vehicles in its class.
- Connectivity features offered as standard by Mahindra make its most tech-laden auto-rickshaw in the industry.
- Easy to drive, navigate, with adequate power and torque to take on any terrain.
- Faster charging and a relatively lower weight battery make the Treo Yaari a well-balanced vehicle on the road.
Kinetic Safar Smart
Mahindra Treo Yaari
- A higher range variant should be available
- More Features would make the Safar Smart even more attractive
- 140 mm of Ground Clearance and 7% Gradeability
- Treo Yaari is a well-packed full-electric auto-rickshaw in the market, however, the higher price in the top variant may classify as expensive for some customers.
- Mahindra should consider introducing fast charging on the Treo platform.
Kinetic Safar Smart
Mahindra Treo Yaari
Safar Smart Comparison with similar trucks
- VS
Kinetic Safar SmartFrom ₹1.45 Lakh *Mahindra Treo Yaari₹1.96 - ₹2.04 Lakh * - VSKinetic Safar SmartFrom ₹1.45 Lakh *Mahindra e-Alfa SuperFrom ₹1.61 Lakh *
- VSKinetic Safar SmartFrom ₹1.45 Lakh *TVS King Deluxe₹1.20 - ₹1.35 Lakh *
- VSKinetic Safar SmartFrom ₹1.45 Lakh *Star Electrika A1From ₹1.16 Lakh *
- VSKinetic Safar SmartFrom ₹1.45 Lakh *Mahindra Treo₹2.92 - ₹3.02 Lakh *
Treo Yaari Comparison with similar trucks
- VSMahindra Treo Yaari₹1.96 - ₹2.04 Lakh *Mahindra Treo₹2.92 - ₹3.02 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo Yaari₹1.96 - ₹2.04 Lakh *Kinetic Safar SmartFrom ₹1.45 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo Yaari₹1.96 - ₹2.04 Lakh *Mahindra e-Alfa SuperFrom ₹1.61 Lakh *
- VSMahindra Treo Yaari₹1.96 - ₹2.04 Lakh *YC Electric Yatri SuperFrom ₹1.69 Lakh *
Recommended Auto Rickshaw
- Popular
- Latest
- Electric
- Bajaj Compact RE₹2.34 - ₹2.36 Lakh*
- Power 10 hp
- GVW 672
- Mileage 40
- Engine 236.2
- Fuel Tank 8
- Fuel Type Petrol
- Electric
- TVS King Deluxe₹1.20 - ₹1.35 Lakh*
- Power 10.46 hp
- Mileage 42.34
- Engine 199.26
- Fuel Tank 8.5
- Fuel Type CNG
- Bajaj Maxima Z₹1.96 - ₹1.98 Lakh*
- Power 8 hp
- GVW 790
- Mileage 29.86
- Engine 470.5
- Fuel Tank 8
- Fuel Type Diesel
- Mahindra Alfa DX CNGPrice Coming Soon
- Power 9.5 hp
- GVW 860
- Mileage 40.2
- Engine 395
- Fuel Tank 40
- Fuel Type CNG
- Electric
- Electric
- Electric
- Electric
User Reviews of Comparison
- Kinetic Safar Smart
- Mahindra Treo Yaari
Service not available after sales
After sale service is not available. Spare parts not available in local place. service center not available in our city....
Affrodable electric passenger carrier
Affrodable electric passenger carrier from Kinetic for daily use. Found them on Pune road recently. Design looks ok and ...
not very happy
After using this Kineitc electric auto for 8 months i’m not very happy with the performance. The battery is heavy, charg...
batter is under power for full day operations.
I checked the product at dealership, the quality is not comes as good. The tyre are small and not high quality. Not able...
can consider for 3-4 passenger carrying business
This is a good options in the passenger electric auto segment but Kinetic needs to give bigger capacity battery because ...
Excellent battery range
The market of electric auto rickshaws has significantly grown in India. However, when it comes to choosing the best elec...
Good e- rickshaw
I like the Treo Yaari by Mahindra. Very Good design and specs like a long-range, new battery, easy charging, and are ...
Auto rickshaw business ke liye faydemand choice
Abhi ki market mein mujhey lagta hai ki kisiko bui diesel, LPG, CNG auto rickshaw na khareed ke electric auto lena chahi...
India ki no.1 auto rickshaw
Maine kuch din pehle Mahindra Treo Yaari khareeda hai. Abhi Indian market mein jitni auto rickshaw hai unmein sab se acc...
Ek value for money auto-rickshaw
Abhi 3 mahina hua main Mahindra Treo Yaari chala raha hoon. Meri tisri auto rickshaw hai yeh aur mera favourite hai teh ...