• Select City

Kinetic Safar Smart Vs Mahindra Treo Yaari Comparison

  • VS
    ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Kinetic Safar Smart
    Kinetic Safar Smart
    ₹ 1.45 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    Talk To Dealer
    VS
  • ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Mahindra Treo Yaari
    Mahindra Treo Yaari
    ₹ 1.79 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    Talk To Dealer
Basic Information
Model Name
Safar Smart
Treo Yaari
Brand Name
On Road Price
₹ 1.45 Lakh
₹ 1.79 Lakh
User Rating
5
Based on 4 Reviews
4.8
Based on 8 Reviews
Body Type
Auto Rickshaw
Auto Rickshaw
Finance Available (EMI)
₹ 2,804.00
₹ 3,457.00
Performance
Max Power
1 hp
2 hp
Displacement (cc)
-
-
Fuel Tank (Litres)
-
-
Engine
-
-
Fuel Type
Electric
Electric
Emission Norms
-
-
Max Torque
-
22 Nm
Acceleration
-
-
Mileage City
-
-
Mileage Highway
-
-
Top Speed
-
24.5
Mileage
-
-
Gradeability (%)
10.2
7
Max Speed (km/h)
-
24.5
Engine Cylinders
-
-
Turning Radius (mm)
-
2900
Range
70
125
Battery Capacity
Lithium-ion 4kwh,Lead Acid 140Ah
3.69
Type of Motor
BLDC Motor
AC induction motor
Charging
Charging Time
2 hrs
2 h 30 min
AC & DC (if available)
-
-
Dimension
Overall Length (mm)
2785
2769
Overall Width (mm)
998
995
Overall Height (mm)
1790
1750
Ground Clearance (mm)
220
142
Wheelbase (mm)
-
2073
Axle Configuration
-
-
Size (Cu. M)
-
-
Length {mm (ft.)}
-
-
Width {mm (ft.)}
-
-
Height {mm (ft.)}
-
-
Transmission & Loading Capacity
Transmission
Direct Drive
Direct Drive
Payload (Kgs)
-
-
GVW / GCW (Kgs)
Kerb Weight (Kgs)
-
276
Gear Box
1 Forward +1 Reverse
1 Forward +1 Reverse
Clutch
-
-
Power SteeringNoNo
Features
Steering
Handle Bar
Handle Bar
A/CNoNo
Cruise ControlNoNo
Navigation System
-
No
TelematicsNoNo
Tiltable SteeringNoNo
Arm-restNoNo
Seat TypeYesYes
Driver Information DisplayYesYes
Adjustable Driver SeatNoNo
Seating Capacity
D+4
D+4
Tubeless TyresNoNo
Seat Belts
-
-
Hill Hold
-
No
Brakes & Suspension
Brakes
Drum Brake
Mechanical Brake
Front Axle
-
-
Front Suspension
-
Helical spring dampener hydraulic shock absorber
Rear Axle
-
-
Rear Suspension
-
Rigid axle leaf spring
ABSNoNo
Parking BrakesYesYes
Body Option & Cabin Type
Chassis Type
Chassis with Cabin
Chassis with Cabin
Body Option
Fuliy Bulit
Fully Bulit
Cabin Type
Day Cabin
Day Cabin
Tiltable CabinNoNo
Tyres
Number of Tyre
3
3
Rear Tyre
-
10R20
Front Tyre
-
10R20
Others
No. Of Axles
-
-
Axle Types
-
-
Body Brakes
-
-
ChassisYesYes
Landing Gear
-
-
Electricals
-
-
Floor Type
-
-
Body Material
-
-
Canopy Length
-
-
Water Tank Capacity (KL)
-
-
Water Tank Type
-
-
No. Of Valves
-
-
Pump Type
-
-
Bulker Type
-
-
Bulker Discharge Pipe
-
-
Bulker Air Inlet Pipe
-
-
Bulker Equipments
-
-
Bulker Electricals
-
-
Bulker Pressure
-
-
Floor Material
-
-
Side Board Material
-
-
Rear Board Material
-
-
External/Interior Surface
-
-
Refrigerating Unit
-
-
Temperature Range
-
-
Loading Platform Area(Sq.ft)
-
-
Battery(Volts)
-
48 V Lithium-ion
Alternator (Amps)
-
-
Fog Lights
-
-

Pros and Cons

  • Pros
  • Cons

    Kinetic Safar Smart

    • Real driving range of 80-100 km makes the Safar Smart a highly useful e-rickshaw for daily business trips
    • Lithium/Lead Acid Battery options
    • All steel body construction makes it safer and more reliable
    • Superior built quality and excellent road presence
    • High-quality aggregates like brakes, suspension, tyre.
    • Comfortable passenger cabin with high leg, knee and shoulder room.
    • 3 years warranty instil confidence in the e-rickshaw

    Mahindra Treo Yaari

    • Treo is powerful, features a rich all-electric auto-rickshaw out in the market.
    • Powerful lithium-ion battery and superior built quality.
    • Higher running range of over 90 km in a single charge.
    • Higher payload and comfortable and safe passenger cabin.
    • Highly affordable e-rickshaw in the segment, the lowest running cost a huge advantage against the IC engine vehicles in its class.
    • Connectivity features offered as standard by Mahindra make its most tech-laden auto-rickshaw in the industry.
    • Easy to drive, navigate, with adequate power and torque to take on any terrain.
    • Faster charging and a relatively lower weight battery make the Treo Yaari a well-balanced vehicle on the road.

    Kinetic Safar Smart

    • A higher range variant should be available
    • More Features would make the Safar Smart even more attractive
    • 140 mm of Ground Clearance and 7% Gradeability

    Mahindra Treo Yaari

    • Treo Yaari is a well-packed full-electric auto-rickshaw in the market, however, the higher price in the top variant may classify as expensive for some customers.
    • Mahindra should consider introducing fast charging on the Treo platform.

Safar Smart Comparison with similar trucks

Treo Yaari Comparison with similar trucks

Recommended Auto Rickshaw

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Mahindra Treo
    Mahindra Treo
    ₹ 2.88 - ₹ 2.98 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 350
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Bajaj Compact RE
    Bajaj Compact RE
    ₹ 2.34 - ₹ 2.36 Lakh*
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 672
    • Mileage 40
    • Engine 236.2
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Mahindra E-Alfa mini
    Mahindra E-Alfa mini
    From ₹ 1.45 Lakh*
    • Power 2 hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Bajaj Maxima Z
    Bajaj Maxima Z
    ₹ 1.96 - ₹ 1.98 Lakh*
    • Power 8 hp
    • GVW 790
    • Mileage -
    • Engine 470.5
    • Fuel Tank 8
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Piaggio Ape E City
    Piaggio Ape E City
    From ₹ 2.84 Lakh*
    • Power 7 hp
    • GVW 713
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload 390
    Talk To Dealer
  • Baxy Express M-TEC
    Baxy Express M-TEC
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power 8 hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine 430
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Baxy BAXY PRO
    Baxy BAXY PRO
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power 10 hp
    • GVW 715
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload 300
    Talk To Dealer
  • Baxy BAXY Rath
    Baxy BAXY Rath
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power 1 hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer
  • Baxy BAXY Zippy Plus
    Baxy BAXY Zippy Plus
    Price Coming Soon
    • Power -
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine -
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload 450
    Talk To Dealer
  • Baxy Express
    Baxy Express
    ₹ 2.06 - ₹ 2.26 Lakh*
    • Power 9 hp
    • GVW -
    • Mileage -
    • Engine 396
    • Fuel Tank -
    • Payload -
    Talk To Dealer

User Reviews of Comparison

  • Kinetic Safar Smart
  • Mahindra Treo Yaari
  • Affrodable electric passenger carrier

    Affrodable electric passenger carrier from Kinetic for daily use. Found them on Pune road recently. Design looks ok and ...

    By ramkumar
    On: Feb 04, 2022
  • not very happy

    After using this Kineitc electric auto for 8 months i’m not very happy with the performance. The battery is heavy, charg...

    By shivam
    On: Dec 17, 2021
  • batter is under power for full day operations.

    I checked the product at dealership, the quality is not comes as good. The tyre are small and not high quality. Not able...

    By nilesh kabra
    On: Oct 09, 2021
  • can consider for 3-4 passenger carrying business

    This is a good options in the passenger electric auto segment but Kinetic needs to give bigger capacity battery because ...

    By nithin kumar
    On: Oct 09, 2021
  • Most trusted electric rickshaw

    Among the many e-rickshaw that you find in the market, believe in only trusted brands that can be worth of your money. A...

    By rajesh
    On: Aug 13, 2022
  • Sasta aur bharosemaand

    Agar affordable price mein ek bharosemaand aur profitable auto rickshaw chahiye toh Mahindra Treo Yaari ek lajawaab opti...

    By deepanshu siagal
    On: Jul 13, 2022
  • Electric auto segment ka best option

    LPG aur CNG auto ka running costs itni zyada bar gayi hai isliye maine recently Mahindra Treo Yaari le liya. 6 mahina ...

    By rakesh kohli
    On: Jun 17, 2022
  • liked the overall vehicle

    I check out Yaari in Bangalore, liked the overall vehicle. Going to purchase, it is my first electric auto rickshaw. Te...

    By mahendra jaju
    On: Apr 27, 2022
  • Very happy with the Treo.

    Best Mahindra electric rickshaw in the market. Cheap and high profit. ...

    By jaspreet
    On: Apr 09, 2022
×
Which is your city ?